|
To prepare healthcare providers to
be ready to recognize, respond, and
treat the victims of weapons of mass
destruction.
After completing this course, the
learner will be able to:
|
1. |
Define acts of terrorism and
weapons of mass destruction. |
| |
|
|
2. |
Identify appropriate forms
of personal protective
equipment and
decontamination for dealing
with acts of terrorism. |
| |
|
|
3. |
Discuss common symptoms and
methods of treatment
associated with exposure to,
or injuries caused by
chemical, biological,
radioactive and nuclear
agents. |
| |
|
|
4. |
syndromic surveillance and
reporting procedures for
acts of terrorism that
involve biological agents. |
| |
|
|
5. |
Discuss access and use of
Federal and CDC resources
for communities after Weapon
of Mass Destruction attacks. |
Weapons of mass destruction are not
new. Historical accounts convey to
us that during the 6th century BC
the Assyrian army used a chemical
agent, rye ergot (a hallucinogen),
to poison the drinking wells of
enemies. The army of the Tartar
nations is recorded as having
purposely provoked an outbreak of
the black plague in 1346 during its
siege of the fortified city of Kaffa
in the Crimea by purposely lobbing
diseased and decaying bodies over
the Kaffa city wall. Some historians
speculate that the results of their
efforts may have had a direct
influence on the Black Death
epidemic, which spread throughout
Europe, and parts of Asia and Africa
as exposed survivors fleeing the
siege provided a convenient means
for the disease to spread (Eitzen,
1997).
We live in an age of high-tech
wonder and terror. There has never
been a time in recorded history
where the ability to afflict injury
and death on large numbers of people
has been as readily available as it
is today. In this time of
technology, Weapons of Mass
Destruction (WMD) are options that
driven individuals or groups may
turn to in order to effect or
inflict damage on the rest of us.
The instruments of mass destruction
of today are known by the
abbreviation CBRNE.
|
CBNE Weapons of Mass Destruction |
As healthcare providers, we have an
obligation to be prepared, to be
ready to recognize and treat those
who may be exposed to these weapons.
Front line medical staff can
identify CBRNE weapons by being
aware of abnormal surges in patient
presentation patterns.
Hospitals and medical facilities in
our country, and throughout the
industrialized world, are designed
to handle patients who arrive
singularly or in small numbers, with
intervals between new cases. An
influx or surge of patients in the
hundreds, even the thousands over a
span ranging from just a few hours
to a period of weeks would strain
even the best-designed health system
to the point of breakdown.
|
WMD Induced Demands on the Health Care System |
|
|
|
Figure 2: (Jagminas, 2011) |
Chemical Weapons Agents (CWAs) are
compounds that pose a hazard to
living tissues when they come in
contact. CWAs may produce
incapacitation, serious injury, or
death. Substances that may be
pressed into service as chemical
weapon agents are all around us.
Common chemicals that can be used to
cause injury are found in virtually
every home. The more concentrated
compounds used in business, in
agriculture, and industry magnify
the potential end-forms which can be
produced. Injuries produced from
weapon grade chemicals can originate
from a variety of causes. It might
be the result of an industrial
accident, industrial sabotage,
damage to a chemical storage area or
stockpile, an act of war, or even
from a directed terrorist attack.
CWAs are a matter of high concern
due to the following characteristics
that increase the chances they may
be used by terrorists on civilian
populations (Arnold, 2009).
|
The components from which
CWAs can be made are widely
available. |
| |
|
 |
Recipes for CWA production
are easy to access worldwide
on the internet as well as
through library or
educational facilities. |
| |
|
 |
CWAs are easily transported
and may be delivered to
victims by a wide variety of
means. |
| |
|
 |
Chemical agents are
difficult to protect
against. |
| |
|
 |
CWAs tend to work quickly
and incapacitate their
targets. |
| |
|
 |
Very few civilian
communities are prepared to
deal with a large-scale
chemical terrorist attack.
|
| |
|
 |
Area hospitals would be
quickly overwhelmed by
casualty surge. |
CWAs are placed in broad groupings
or categories according to the
primary effect they have on living
humans or animals (Arnold, 2009)
(Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention Chemical Agents by
Category, 2012).
|
1. |
Vesicating or blistering
agents - Chemicals that
severely blister the eyes,
respiratory tract, and skin
on contact. |
| |
|
|
2. |
Blood agents - Toxins that
affect the body by altering
blood functions such as
oxygen carrying capability. |
| |
|
|
3. |
Pulmonary agents - Chemicals
that cause severe irritation
or swelling of the
respiratory tract such as
the lining of the nose,
throat, and lungs. |
| |
|
|
4. |
Incapacitating agents -
Toxins that make people
unable to think clearly or
that cause an altered state
of consciousness. Riot
control agents are sometimes
placed in this category. |
| |
|
|
5. |
Nerve agents - Highly
poisonous compounds that
work by preventing the
nervous system from working
properly. |
"Persistent Agents" is the term used
for those chemical warfare
substances that remain dangerous for
a considerable amount of time unless
specific actions are taken to
destroy or neutralize them. These
substances tend usually to be a
liquid or solid form at normal room
temperatures.
"Non-persistent agents" are those
compounds that typically remain in
effective concentrations for only a
short time. These chemicals tend to
be released as either; 1) airborne
particles of a solid (i.e. mace,
pepper spray), 2) droplets of a
liquid (e.g. the sarin vapor used in
the Tokyo subway attacks), or as 3)
true gases.
Airborne particles are easily
affected by prevailing weather
conditions and may be quickly
dispersed, so that the locality in
which they have been released soon
ceases to be contaminated.
Victims usually are exposed to
chemical agents via three main
routes:
|
1. |
Skin (by liquid or high
vapor concentrations).
|
| |
|
|
2. |
Eyes (liquid or vapor). |
| |
|
|
3. |
Respiratory tract (vapor
inhalation). |
| |
|
Depending on the agent, the method
of delivery, and the amount
(concentration) of exposure,
chemical warfare agent effects may
be seen immediately or effects may
be delayed. Large inhalation
exposures to nerve agents or the
tissue irritants known as mustards
are likely to kill people
immediately. Small exposures on the
skin to the very same nerve agents
and mustards may initially only
irritate, in the manner of poison
ivy or a very annoying insect bite,
yet skin exposure to these chemicals
is dangerous and will progress far
beyond the irritation present at
first. All individuals exposed to
such agents need to be carefully
observed for slowly developing or
delayed effects.
First responders to a chemical
warfare agent attack are at serious
risk from the environment steeped
with concentrations of the chemical
contaminant, which is known as a hot
zone. They can come into skin
contact with the particles of
chemical, liquids in fluid or
droplet form, or even inhale gaseous
vapors. Responders are also at risk
if they handle skin and clothing of
victims, especially if a liquid
chemical agent was used. Ideally,
emergency personnel will wear
personal protective equipment
specific to the hazardous material
present, decontaminate the victims
immediately, provide initial medical
support and transport to the
victims, and have access to specific
antidotes to counteract harmful
effects.
|
Fast
Fact:
Particularly for chemical events, a good rule
for safety is to move quickly uphill, upwind,
upstream, and upgrade from the hot zone area of
danger. |
Chemicals known as nerve agents are
highly poisonous compounds that
prevent the nervous system from
working properly. The purpose of
nerve agents is not so much to kill,
but rather to rapidly incapacitate
large numbers of people for extended
periods, tying up resources and
causing the collapse of support
infrastructure. Many people exposed
to nerve agents do die however,
depending on the agent used and
amount of exposure, yet death is
rarely the main objective of their
use.
Under normal room temperature and
atmospheric pressure, nerve agents
are volatile liquids, which may seem
contradictory as they are referred
to by the common usage name of
"nerve gases". This can be explained
by their chemical nature. Being
volatile means, the gas tends to
evaporate quickly. Nerve agent
vapors "e.g. nerve gas" are heavier
than air and once airborne; tend to
sink into low sheltered areas such
as stairwells or basements. The most
volatile of the nerve agents is
sarin, which evaporates at about the
same rate and temperature as water.
The least volatile agent, VX, has a
consistency similar to that of motor
oil, and is 100-150 times more toxic
than sarin when exposed on skin. All
chemical warfare nerve agents are
able to rapidly penetrate skin and
clothing largely due to their high
volatility.
|
A Few Recent Chemical/Nerve Warfare Incidents |
Currently there are five main
chemical warfare nerve agents
available. Nerve agents are
separated into two main groupings.
The "G" series, whose first initial
connotes the German scientists who
researched and developed them, and
the "V" series where the initial
represents Venomous who some authors
credit as research branching from
crop pesticide studies. All are
banned by international law and
treaties and are considered to be
exclusively military weapons. These
five nerve agents are:
|
Tabun (also referred to by
the military designation
"GA") |
| |
|
|
Sarin (GB) |
| |
|
|
Soman (GD) |
| |
|
|
Cyclohexylsarin (GF) |
| |
|
|
VX (along with the less
recognized subtypes VE, VG,
VM, VR) |
A third series of chemical warfare
nerve gas agents, known as Novichok
Nerve Agents have recently become
known. Novichok is the Russian word
for "newcomer", and information
regarding these compounds originates
from 1992 disclosures to the media
by a chemist working in a Russian
military chemical complex who voiced
concerns that defense conversion
money from the west was being used
instead for development of chemical
weapons. The Novichok series, which
is said to be more powerful and more
deadly than the previous generations
of nerve gases, brings a handling
advantage with it in the form of a
binary formula, where two different
components can be handled separately
in relative safety with the deadly
nerve agent only appearing when the
two parts are mixed, such as during
the detonation of an explosive
device (Velez-Daubon, 2012).
The new edge of safety the Novichok
series of nerve agents brings to its
handlers, if not to end recipients,
has prompted newer spins on older
generation chemical warfare
compounds. Known binary nerve agents
now include:
|
Novichok - particularly
Novichok-5, Novichok-7 |
| |
|
|
GB binary - sarin, GB2 |
| |
|
|
GD binary - soman, GD2 |
| |
|
|
VX binary - VX2 |
In their active forms, the major
nerve agents possess chemical
structures somewhat similar to the
common commercial organophosphate
pesticide Malathion. In action,
these warfare agents initially
stimulate and then paralyze nerve
transmissions throughout the body,
primarily by inhibiting
acetylcholinesterase a key enzyme in
the nervous system. This mechanism
of action leads to hyperactivation
of cholinergic pathways causing
convulsive seizures and respiratory
failure.
Diagnosis
Diagnostic testing is not reliable
in identifying nerve agents in blood
or urine. Health providers must make
their treatment decisions based on
the signs and symptoms a patient
presents with and on information
about the type of chemical exposure,
if it is known.
|
Nerve Agent Onset |
Signs |
Symptoms |
Vapors:
Seconds to minutes
Liquids:
Minutes to hours |
|
Pinpoint pupils,
eye irritation |
| |
|
|
Bronchoconstriction |
| |
|
|
Respiratory
arrest |
| |
|
|
Hypersalivation |
| |
|
|
Increased
secretions |
| |
|
|
Diarrhea |
| |
|
|
Poor
concentration |
| |
|
|
Seizures |
|
Moderate exposure:
|
Diffuse
muscle cramping, runny nose, difficulty
breathing, eye pain, dim vision, sweating,
muscle tremors. |
High Exposure:
|
Sudden loss
of consciousness, seizures, flaccid paralysis
(late sign) |
|
|
Figure 4: (Arnold, 2009) (Agency for Toxic
Substances and Disease Registry, 2011). |
Treatment
Treatment of victims exposed to
chemical warfare nerve agents is
similar to the treatment of those
poisoned by organophosphate
insecticides. With decontamination
and appropriate initial therapy,
serious signs and symptoms of nerve
agent toxicity rarely last more than
a couple of hours.
Victims with symptoms require
immediate treatment with atropine IV
or IM. Atropine aids breathing by
drying secretions and opening
airways. Atropine also blocks other
effects of poisoning, such as
nausea, vomiting, abdominal
cramping, low heart rate, and
sweating. Atropine will not prevent
or reverse paralysis. Pralidoxime
chloride is a medication with
effects similar to the more readily
available atropine and may be given.
An emergency nerve agent treatment
kit known as the Mark I Kit has been
designed for military personnel
self-administration in the field. It
consists of two spring-loaded
devices for self-injection, one each
containing atropine and pralidoxime
chloride. The Mark I Kit is not
available for civilian use, yet can
be obtained on an "at time of need"
basis from Federal Emergency
Management Agency (FEMA) controlled
regional storage facilities.
The peak toxic effects of nerve
agents occur within minutes to hours
and go away within a 24-hour period.
People who were exposed but show no
symptoms should be observed for at
least 18 hours as some symptoms have
a gradual onset.
Vesicating or Blister Agents are
often referred to by the slang term
"mustards". This is not the yellow
stuff found on hot dogs at the
ballpark. Nitrogen mustard (HN 1-3),
Sulfur mustard (H or HD, also
referred to as "mustard gas"),
Lewisite (L), and Phosgene oxime (CX)
all cause intense irritation,
inflammation, and corrosive burning
on contact with living tissue.
Mustard agents rapidly penetrate
cell walls and generate a highly
toxic reaction that disrupts cell
function and causes cell death. This
chemical reaction is temperature
dependent and is aided by the
presence of water, which explains
why warm, moist tissues like eyes,
airways, armpits, or crotches are
affected more severely.
Blister agents have the consistency
of oily liquids that actually do
possess an odor somewhat reminiscent
to that of mustard greens, onion,
garlic, or even horseradish. They
are highly soluble in oils, fats,
and organic solvents. They quickly
penetrate skin and most covering
materials or textiles, including
rubber. Sulfur mustard, the nemesis
of WWI trench warfare, is a
persistent agent with low volatility
at cool temperatures that quickly
becomes a major vapor hazard as
temperatures rise. Exposure to
mustard vapors, not the more
concentrated mustard liquid, is a
primary medical concern, as mustard
vapor is three times more toxic than
a similar concentration of cyanide
gas. Skin exposure to as little as
one teaspoon of liquid sulfur
mustard (seven grams) is lethal to
half of those exposed.
Diagnosis
Diagnosis of vesicant agent /
blister agent / mustard exposure is
based on observations of the
persons signs and symptoms as well
as reports from the time of
exposure. No laboratory tests are
diagnostic.
Vesicating agents primarily injure
the skin, eyes, respiratory tract,
GI tissues, and blood system.
Wherever tissue is exposed to the
agent, the symptom pattern will
reflect corrosive irritation of that
area. Skin exposure commonly results
in an initial rash followed by
blistering similar to a
partial-thickness burn. Vapor
exposure damages the upper
respiratory tract. Mustards
penetrate cell walls in less than 2
minutes; yet, serious signs and
symptoms may be delayed from 4-6
hours (the range can be from 1-24
hours).
Treatment
Decontamination within 2 minutes of
exposure is the most important
intervention for people who have
skin exposure to any of the tissue
irritant mustards. Any living tissue
affected undergoes irreversible cell
damage. Decontamination therefore
remains urgent even if a person
shows no obvious sign and symptoms
to an initial exposure.
A new topical product designed to
neutralize the toxicity of blister
agents, and to an extent nerve
agents, was approved for use by the
FDA in July of 2003. This product is
known by the acronym RSDL, which
stands for Reactive Skin
Decontamination Lotion, and acts
within seconds of being applied to
the skin. RSDL is a creamy lotion
currently packaged on a foam
applicator in a single use pouch and
is available for use by military and
some civilian emergency services
personnel. For best effect, the
lotion should be applied within
three minutes of skin contamination.
The residue left by the lotion,
which is non-toxic, should be washed
away at the earliest convenience (Beary,
2012).
Treatment of blister agent exposure
following decontamination is
symptomatic. For most blistering
agents, there is no agent-specific
antidote. The blister agent Lewisite
(chlorovinyldichloroarsine) is the
only agent in this grouping with a
specific treatment. Lewisite is an
arsenical vesicant that is a
colorless to brown liquid with a
fruity or geranium-like odor. A
scavenger molecule known as
dimercaprol or British anti-Lewisite
works to bind the Lewisite compound,
creating an effective antidote, when
given early as early as possible
following exposure.
Upper airway obstruction warrants
aggressive airway management as
tissues permeated by the vesicant
agents will continue to worsen.
Systematic burn care is essential
because skin lesions are slow to
heal and prone to infection.
Chemical warfare agents that affect
the victim by being absorbed into
the circulating blood stream are
referred to by the term Blood
Agents. Many of these poisons
contain cyanide ions, which once
entered into the body and blood,
chemically inactivate cytochrome
oxidase, an essential component
whose absence prevents cells from
utilizing oxygen. This means that
although the persons blood is
delivering oxygen to their tissues,
the cells are poisoned and unable to
take up the oxygen. The result is
asphyxia with a small degree of
cyanosis. Cyanide compounds act very
rapidly, causing death within the
first ten minutes of severe
exposure. Fatalities may occur with
inhalation or ingestion.
Cyanide based compounds are
frighteningly easy to obtain.
Industrial uses for hydrogen cyanide
are numerous. The liquid form of a
cyanide agent could be inserted into
a water supply or disguised in a
strongly flavored food or liquid.
Contrary to popular literature and
entertainment media, cyanide
compounds in the form of a gas make
a poor weapon. The gaseous form is
very volatile, disappearing rapidly
into the environment. The gaseous
form of cyanide poses a grave threat
to anyone handling it, especially
those releasing it. In addition, the
gaseous form either kills or has
minimal effect, making it an
all-or-nothing agent.
Diagnosis
Due to the short time interval
between exposure and death,
diagnosis must be made by
observation and any known available
facts of exposure. A bitter almond
odor associated with the patient may
suggest cyanide poisoning; however,
the lack of odor is not a reliable
exposure gauge. The effects of blood
agents include metabolic acidosis,
hyperventilation, headache, a venous
blood-O2 level above normal, and
hypotension. The mucosal membranes
and skin of casualties tend to
appear an unusual dark red because
the tissue cells cannot utilize
oxygen. Higher exposure levels
provoke coma, convulsions, and
cessation of respiration and
heartbeat. Laboratory confirmations
of the presence of cyanide or
thiocyanate in blood or urine are
useful for later confirmation of the
initial diagnosis.
Treatment
Supplemental oxygen by mask followed
by intubation with 100% O2 is the
preferred initial treatment.
Hydroxocobalamin, sodium nitrite and
sodium thiosulfate are antidotes to
cyanide when administered
immediately. The natural form of
vitamin B12, hydroxocobalamin, is
used in the treatment of cyanide
toxicity and marketed under the name
Cyanokit. A standard dose of 5 gm.
IV over 15-minutes, with a second
dose given in severe toxicity binds
cellular and circulating cyanide
molecules, which will then be
excreted in the urine. IV sodium
thiosulfate reacts with cyanide to
form thiocyanate, which is excreted
by the kidneys. Amyl nitrite
inhalation, 1 ampoule (0.2 ml) every
5 minutes, may be helpful as it
generates methemoglobin that binds
molecular cyanide. Full protection
from cyanide vapors can be achieved
with activated charcoal filters
(Nelson, 2011).
Incapacitating agents include a wide
range of chemicals whose actions
produce physiologic or mental
inability to function. In military
terms, these agents are referred to
as Harassing Weapons. Their purpose
is to confuse, disorient, frighten,
and render individuals incapable of
performing any semblance of normal
activities.
An incapacitating agent known as
3-quinuclidinyl benzilate (QNB or BZ)
may be the most commonly used
compound of this nature currently in
use. QNB has played a role in
military and civil unrest actions in
several countries such as Mozambique
and Bosnia. There are no reports of
its use in the United States. QNB
has an ability to cause intense
visual and aural hallucinations in
those exposed to it, producing an
overwhelming loss of reality. It is
pharmacologically related to
commonly used anticholinergic drugs
and traces of this chemical are
present within some over-the-counter
sleeping medications (Holstege,
2012).
Lacrimating Agents (tear gas) are
incapacitating agents used in the
United States and other countries,
primarily for riot control. The mode
of action of these agents is an
intense immobilizing irritation to
the eyes, respiratory tract, and
skin. Weapon grade versions of these
agents can provoke fatal
inflammatory reactions in vulnerable
populations, particularly the very
young and very old.
New incapacitating agents are
cropping up all the time. In October
2002, Soviet security officials
flooded a crowded Moscow theater
with an aerosolized form of the
common post-surgical pain medication
fentanyl. This resulted in most of
the 750 hostages held by terrorists
being rescued. Unfortunately, it
also meant that 117 people perished
with no accurate account of how many
deaths were directly due to the
incapacitating agent used (Miller,
2012).
Treatment
Treatment of incapacitating agents
is symptomatic, with irrigation of
eyes and supplemental oxygen being
the most common initial treatment.
Those exposed require monitoring for
individual effects to the chemical
agent used.
Pulmonary or Choking Agents are
chemicals, which act directly on the
tissues of the lungs and respiratory
system. Many of these chemicals are
commonly used in agriculture and
industry and are readily accessible
to individuals willing to break the
law. They include such compounds as
phosgene, chlorine, diphosgene,
chloropicrin, oxides of nitrogen,
and sulfur dioxide.
Pulmonary agents are chiefly gaseous
compounds or aerosolized liquids.
Onset of effects are often
immediate, yet may be delayed as
long as 24 hours, and rarely, up to
72 hours. Individuals may be
asymptomatic following an initial
low exposure. Lack of symptoms does
not put them in the clear as tissue
irritation and swelling can begin
hours after exposure to the agent.
Phosgene (CG) is a good example of a
pulmonary agent chemical weapon due
to the intriguing dichotomy of its
legitimate use in numerous
industries and past use as a terror
weapon by both warring nations and
extremist groups. In industry,
phosgene is a valuable reagent that
smells of freshly cut grass or
slightly moldy hay, and is used in
the synthesis of pharmaceuticals and
other organic compounds. As a
chemical warfare weapon, phosgene is
a pulmonary toxicant. Exposure to it
leads quickly to injury of the
respiratory tract and suffocation.
Phosgene has an insidious side, with
inhalation initially having an
irritant effect similar to tear gas,
and a somewhat delayed extremely
serious onset of subsequent
pulmonary edema developing around 4
hours after exposure (Crandall,
2012).
|
The
Urgent Care Clinic next to the City Center mass
transit station where Wallace works has been
frantically busy. Rush hour adults from the
transit station began to pour in, eyes
streaming, coughing hoarsely. Amongst the noisy
crowded chaos, Wallace smells the heavy cloying
odor of molding hay or newly cut grass.
One
call to EMS activates the citys emergency
management plan. Following the plan, a staff
member leads ambulatory clients away from city
center to an open area uphill and upwind from
the mass transit station. EMS moves quickly to
set up triage and decontamination units outside
the suspected hot zone. Workers arrive to
evacuate the more severely affected from the
Urgent Care.
Wallaces call was one of several received
almost simultaneously from several key spots
around the transit station. Police and aid units
were immediately dispatched, setting up
blockades to keep civilians safely away from the
area and establish triage areas. Hospital and
care centers in an expanding zone were notified
by EMS to activate their emergency plans and
prepare for incoming, with updates given as more
information was gathered.
Simultaneously, the city emergency center became
activated to coordinate efforts and direct the
flow of assistance into the needed area while
bringing the injured out. Less severe cases
going to more distant hospitals, keeping
capacity for severe injuries available close to
the scene. |
After Action Notes:
|
Emergency management in a
potential WMD event is not
about rushing people
through, it centers on a
smooth swift flow toward the
next station in the links of
a chain of care. |
| |
|
|
All health agencies and
establishments must have
written plans for dealing
with emergencies. Please,
know your plan. Know where
the plan is. Know the first
steps toward safety. |
| |
|
|
Always move toward the next
stage of care, however, if
unsure what the next step
is; locate a place of
safety, let authorities know
where you are, and await
direction. It is more
important to wait a little
while to find the correct
next step then to rush
blindly in an unsafe
direction. |
|
Diagnosis
No specific tests are readily
available, though a good history may
help identify source and exposure
characteristics. Chest x-rays may
help confirm presence of pulmonary
infiltrates. Initial signs of
respiratory tract irritation such as
coughing, runny nose, or wheezing
may be followed by the development
of a pulmonary infiltrate and
shortness of breath. Chest tightness
often progresses to laryngeal spasm.
Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome
(ARDS) is common, leading to non-cardiogenic
pulmonary edema.
Treatment
No specific antidotes are available
for pulmonary or choking agents.
Aggressive pulmonary lavage has not
been shown to be effective at this
time. Treatment must center on
aggressively maintaining the airway
along with management of the
secretions. High dose steroids may
be employed in an effort to prevent
pulmonary edema. Treatment of
pulmonary edema centers on the use
of mechanical ventilation with
positive end exhalation pressure
(PEEP) to maintain a PO2 above 60 mm
Hg.
Disease as a means of terror and
widespread destruction has been used
since before written history. In
modern times, the ability to isolate
or modify a particular organism,
then replicate it in a controlled
environment has encouraged the use
of illness as living weapons. The
threat of biological agents used as
weapons is now higher than at any
time in recorded history (Dire,
2011).
Most biological weapon agents are
bacteria and viruses, along with the
toxins they produce. However, any
living organism able to cause
illness or death in humans or in
stock animals can conceivably be a
biological weapon. The advantages of
biological agents include:
|
Death or incapacitation of
the target population |
| |
|
|
Ability of certain
biological agents to
continue proliferating in
affected individuals and,
potentially, in the local
population and surrounding
areas |
| |
|
|
The relatively low cost of
producing various biological
weapons |
| |
|
|
Insidious symptoms that can
mimic endemic diseases
|
| |
|
|
The difficulty of
immediately detecting the
use of a biological agent
due to the incubation period
preceding onset of illness
(or the slow onset of
symptoms) |
| |
|
|
High incidence of panic
associated with biological
weapon use |
| |
|
|
Preservation of property and
physical surroundings
(compared with conventional
or nuclear weapons) |
Agents of Biologic Warfare are
categorized into three categories -
A, B, and C - based on their
likelihood of use, how easily they
can be dispersed into a target
population, as well as the severity
of illness or death that they might
be expected to produce (Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention,
Bioterrorism Agents by Category,
2012).
Category "A" Bio-agents are bacteria
or viruses that pose a high level of
risk to the public due to the
following characteristics they
share:
|
1. |
Can be easily disseminated
or transmitted from person
to person |
| |
|
|
2. |
Result in high mortality
rates |
| |
|
|
3. |
Have the potential for major
public health impact |
| |
|
|
4. |
Might cause public panic and
social disruption |
| |
|
|
5. |
Mandate special action in
the way of public health
preparedness |
Category "A" Bio-agents include:
|
Anthrax (Bacillus anthracis) |
| |
|
|
Botulism (Clostridium
botulinum toxin) |
| |
|
|
Plague (Yersinia pestis) |
| |
|
|
Smallpox (Variola major) |
| |
|
|
Tularemia (Francisella
tularensis) |
| |
|
|
Viral hemorrhagic fevers
(members of the filovirus
and arenavirus families) |
| |
|
|
 |
Filoviruses - Ebola, Marburg |
|
|
|
 |
Arenaviruses - Lassa,
Machupo |
Category "B" Bio-agents are the
second highest level of concern.
These organisms pose a risk because
they:
|
1. |
Tend to be moderately easy
to disseminate |
| |
|
|
2. |
May result in moderate
morbidity rates and lower
mortality rates than the
category "A" bio-agents |
| |
|
|
3. |
Require CDC diagnostic and
enhanced disease
surveillance abilities to
detect or track |
| |
|
Category "B" Bio-agents include:
|
Brucellosis (Brucella
species) |
| |
|
|
Epsilon toxin (from
Clostridium perfringens) |
| |
|
|
Food Safety Threats (e.g.,
Salmonella, E. coli select
strains, Shigella) |
| |
|
|
Glanders (Burkholderia
mallei) |
| |
|
|
Melioidosis (Burkholderia
pseudomallei) |
| |
|
|
Psittacosis (Chlamydia
psittaci) |
| |
|
|
Q fever (Coxiella burnetii) |
| |
|
|
Ricin toxin (extract from
castor beans) |
| |
|
|
Staphylococcal enterotoxin B |
| |
|
|
Typhus fever (Rickettsia
prowazekii) |
| |
|
|
Viral encephalitis
(especially alphaviruses
such as Venezuelan, equine
encephalitis, western equine
encephalitis, eastern equine
encephalitis) |
| |
|
|
Water safety threats (e.g.,
Vibrio cholerae,
Cryptosporidium parvum) |
Category "C" Bio-agents are
pathogens that have the potential to
be engineered for mass
dissemination. These organisms pose
a risk because of:
|
1. |
Availability |
| |
|
|
2. |
Ease of production and/or
dissemination |
| |
|
|
3. |
Potential for major health
impact on populations |
| |
|
Category "C" Bio-agents include:
|
Nipah virus |
| |
|
|
Hantavirus |
| |
|
|
Tick borne hemorrhagic
fevers |
| |
|
|
Tick borne encephalitis |
| |
|
|
Yellow Fever |
| |
|
|
Multidrug resistant
tuberculosis |
Weapons of mass destruction in
biological warfare focus on the
deliberate spread of disease causing
organisms or organic toxins among
humans, animals, or plants. Disease
results when these new pathologies
enter into the target population and
begin to multiply, usually after an
incubation period. During this
incubation period, and even
afterward during the time when
active symptoms are displayed, WMD
disease organisms may have the
ability to self-spread into other
available hosts or areas, beginning
the process anew. This
self-dissemination process can be
slow a slow increase or enlarge
blindingly fast. With many
biological warfare agents, as the
initial symptoms of quick spreading
disease becomes apparent those
affected become incapacitated,
creating a societal drain of
resources as well as rapid loss of
the very personnel able to contain
the outbreak, or those needed to
give care to the affected.
Incapacitation continues until those
infected begin to recover, become
stabilized in their infirmity, or
die.
Biological weapons are living
organisms that tend to have an
ability to adapt to new environments
as well as treatments that used to
work. Biological agent exposure
routes are (Eitzen &Takafuji, 1997):
|
Inhalation into the lungs as
an aerosol (Lungs) |
| |
|
|
Oral ingestion into the
digestive tract in food or
water (Digestive) |
| |
|
|
Dermal absorption through
the skin, or placed on the
skin to cause damage to the
integument (Skin) |
| |
|
|
Percutaneous penetration by
being injected or somehow
forced into bodily tissue
(Tissue) |
Organic toxins may also form the
basis for biological weapons of mass
destruction. These toxins themselves
are non-living products of plants or
microorganisms and can be collected
and "harvested", even stored in
advance, for use as a weapon later.
Toxins from microbes such as
botulinum toxin or enterotoxin B
find themselves alongside the
products of plants such as ricin
from castor beans and even products
of shellfish, like saxitoxin.
Toxins, like the synthetic agents of
chemical warfare, can only affect
those who are exposed to them, and
have no ability to reproduce or
produce any form of transmissible
disease.
Diagnosis
Symptomatic treatment is not enough
when dealing with biological warfare
agents. An exact diagnosis of the
disease is essential, and has
consequences beyond its normal
importance in the treatment of any
individual patient. The origin of
the disease outbreak must be
identified quickly in order to
predict further spread of the
organism, estimate control
requirements, and contain the
disease source. For these reasons,
and for the ability to provide your
patients with the best possible
individualized care, early
notification of public health
officials and epidemiological
specialists is vital.
|
Fast Fact:
|
Isolation is the
restriction of an infected person |
| |
|
|
Quarantine is the
restriction of an exposed person |
|
Even when everything runs smoothly,
the gathering of necessary
information along with diagnostic
testing requires time. The more
sophisticated the test, the more
time results tend to take. In the
event a biological warfare agent is
released, delays in instituting
system level responses while waiting
on "a definitive diagnosis" vastly
increases the size and degree of the
problem. It may be necessary to
begin initial treatment in response
to symptom type, patterns of
location and exposure of involved
individuals before a specific
causative organism is determined.
This method of early mass response
goes against hard-learned habits for
many practitioners, however, by
involving local emergency response
authorities and public health
officials the determination of
whether aggressive treatment of
large populations is needed can be
made as early as possible.
|
Indications of Possible Biologic Weapon Event |
|
Abnormally high numbers of
patients with similar
symptoms. |
| |
|
|
Large numbers of unexplained
symptoms, disease, or
deaths. |
| |
|
|
Presence of disease (or
strain) not locally endemic. |
| |
|
|
Higher than expected
morbidity and mortality in
known disease. |
| |
|
|
Failure of a known disease
to respond to traditional
therapy. |
| |
|
|
Out of season, out of region
disease presentation. |
| |
|
|
Atypical patient
distribution. |
| |
|
|
Atypical disease
presentation. |
| |
|
|
Similar pathogen
characteristics/genetics
from distinctly different
sources. |
| |
|
|
Unusual, atypical,
genetically engineered or
antiquated strains of
pathogens. |
| |
|
|
Sudden, unexplained spikes
in disease incidence. |
| |
|
|
Unusual clustering of
similar illnesses in
non-connected areas. |
| |
|
|
Induced transmission of
toxins or organisms, (i.e.
by aerosol, food, water). |
| |
|
|
Abnoraml animal death or
illness congruent to death
or illness in humans. |
|
|
Figure 5: (Dire, 2011) |
Anthrax
Bacillus anthracis or anthrax is a
large, non-motile, gram-positive,
spore-forming, aerobic bacillus that
can be found worldwide in both
domestic and wild animals. In
humans, apart from its appearance as
a biological warfare agent, the
occurrence of anthrax is exceedingly
rare. In the United States an
average of one naturally occurring
case per year has been reported
during the last twenty years (Dire,
2011).
Anthrax infection may be determined
by symptom presentation as well as;
|
Blood or Sputum Culture |
| |
|
|
ELISA (Enzyme Linked
Immunoassay) |
| |
|
|
PCR (Polymerase Chain
Reaction) |
| |
|
|
DFA (Direct Fluorescent
Antibody) testing |
Plague
Plague (Yersinia pestis, a gram
negative, non-motile, non-sporulating
coccobacillus) is an ancient enemy
of civilization. It has been the
cause of three great human pandemics
in the 6th, 14th, and 20th
centuries. Its preferred means of
transport, the oriental rat flea,
has greatly aided the spread of
plague in the past. Military
scientists have gone one better
however, they have concentrated on
the development of a primary
pneumonic plague, which if untreated
has a reported mortality rate of
close to 100-percent. Air is now the
vector of choice in this new and
improved biologic agent of mass
destruction (Dire, 2011).
Diagnosis of plague may be made by
the clinical presentation of painful
buboes (lymph node swelling,
especially evident in the groin),
fever, severe malaise, and exposure
to rodents or fleas. Cultures of
blood, bubo aspirate, sputum or
cerebrospinal fluid can demonstrate
results in 48 hours. PCR (Polymerase
Chain Reaction) testing is specific
for the presence of plague; however,
it may not be available in all
regions.
Smallpox
The virus Variola, aka smallpox was
declared "extinct in the wild" in a
1980 declaration issued by the World
Health Organization. As a bioweapon
in waiting, on the other hand, it
gets top marks. Smallpox is highly
infectious when spread in an
aerosolized form and is associated
with a high death rate as well as
good secondary spread. In 2003, the
United States began vaccination of
military personnel, however the
majority of the US population
currently has no immunity, vaccine
is in short supply, and no effective
treatment exists for the disease.
Diagnosis of smallpox falls largely
on alertness of medical personnel
for the differences of smallpox
lesion development from their more
benign counterparts found in
chickenpox or allergic contact
dermatitis. In smallpox the rash
from which pustules arise has a
centrifugal distribution (greatest
concentration of lesions on the face
and distal extremities) with the
presence of raised lesions in the
same stage of development occurring
on any one part of the body (e.g.,
on the leg, face, arm all of the
lesions are in the same development
stage). Swab cultures can be taken
of formed lesions in order to
confirm diagnosis, and observation
of the characteristic viral
particles with electron microscopy
is definitive. For more rapid
testing, a Gispen modified silver
stain is available yet rather
insensitive, and a gel diffusion
test in which vesicular fluid
antigen from one of the pustule
lesions can be incubated with
vaccine hyper immune serum may be
used.
Botulism Toxin
Clostridium botulinum is an
anaerobic spore-forming,
gram-positive bacillus. The seven
subtypes of botulinum toxin are most
deadly toxins that we know of.
Botulinum toxin is so incredibly
lethal, easy to manufacture and
weaponize that it is considered one
of the most-likely-to-be-seen
biological warfare agents for the
near future. As a weapon, exposure
is likely to occur following
inhalation of aerosolized toxin or
ingestion of toxin-contaminated food
(Dire, 2011).
All seven subtypes of botulinum
toxin act by similar mechanisms
whether they are ingested or
inhaled. The toxin binds with
presynaptic nerve terminals at both
cholinergic autonomic sites and
neuromuscular junctions to inflict
muscular weakness and paralysis.
|
Bio Agent |
Signs & Symptoms |
Handling |
|
Botulism
(all 7 subtypes) |
|
Incubation - None with
refined toxin. From 12-72
hours for spores. |
| |
|
|
Excess mucus, speech
difficulty, dysphagia,
dizziness, difficulty moving
eyes, mild pupil dilatation,
nystagmus. |
| |
|
|
Unsteady gait, symmetric
descending weakness, flaccid
paralysis, respiratory
failure |
|
|
Standard Precautions. |
| |
|
|
No post exposure prophylaxis
available. |
|
|
Figure 10: (Dire, 2011). |
Diagnosis of botulinum toxin
exposure relies heavily on clinical
examination skills. Some initial
signs include blurred vision, speech
difficulty, dysphagia, dizziness,
difficulty moving eyes, and
nystagmus. An unsteady gait with
symmetric descending muscular
weakness is a strong indication of
exposure. This generally proceeds
into flaccid paralysis and
respiratory failure. Nasal swabs can
be obtained for PCR and toxin
assays, and toxin serum assays can
be ran (Woods, 2012).
Tularemia
Tularemia is usually thought of as a
disease of animals, thus the common
names of "deer tick fever" or
"rabbit fever". It makes the "A"
list of biologic weapons for two
excellent reasons. It is incredibly
incapacitating, and very easy to
contract when in a weapons form.
Tularemia can be distributed by
aerosol. It can pass from person to
person by open wound contact. Even
insects that bite an infected animal
or person can spread Tularemia. Just
as in both anthrax and plague,
several forms of tularemia are
possible and may involve the skin,
lymph nodes, lungs, or other organs.
Added to that, those recovering from
tularemias effects can anticipate a
protracted recovery, creating a
drain on available health resources.
|
Bio Agent |
Signs & Symptoms |
Handling |
|
Tularemia
|
|
Incubation 3-6 days. |
| |
|
|
Enlarged lymph nodes, fever
headache, cough, muscle
aches. |
| |
|
|
In the skin form at least
one large skin chancre-like
ulceration is common. |
| |
|
|
In the respiratory form
pneumonia, chest pain,
vomiting, joint pain, sore
throat, abdominal pain,
diarrhea. |
|
|
Standard Precautions with
droplet precautions for both
pulmonary presentation and
lab workers. |
| |
|
|
Post exposure prophylaxis is
available. |
|
|
Figure 11: (Dire, 2011). |
Diagnosis of tularemia, in the
absence of a known outbreak, often
depends upon laboratory findings as
the physical symptoms can be wide
ranging though generally
debilitating. Both serologic
bacterial agglutination and ELISA
testing is effective, and culture of
Francisella tularensis can be
obtained from specimens of blood,
sputum, a lesion, or a wide variety
of exudates.
In yet to be diagnosed cases an
experienced practitioner may have a
high level of suspicion on observing
the presence of a single somewhat
characteristic "heaped" ulceration
in a cutaneous tularemia infection,
which will often be found on an
extremity. While these chancre-like
ulcerations are the most commonly
observed sign of tularemia, they
will be absent in clients whose
infection does not involve the skin
(Dire, 2011).
Viral Hemorrhagic Fever
The term viral hemorrhagic fevers (VHFs)
refer to a group of loosely related
illnesses characterized by
hemorrhage and fever. They are
caused by several distinct families
of viruses and are related mainly by
the symptoms that they manifest.
Some VHFs cause relatively mild
illness. Most however are severe and
life-threatening, involving multiple
organ system damage. All of the VHFs,
with the exception of dengue, can
potentially be transmitted via
airborne aerosol. This capability,
combined with their ability to cause
serious illness has resulted in
their consideration as biological
weapons.
|
Bio Agent |
Signs & Symptoms |
Handling |
|
Viral hemorrhagic
fevers
(e.g., Ebola, Marburg, Lassa, Machupo
Hantavirus, Nipah virus)
|
|
Incubation days to months. |
| |
|
|
Fever, flushing, red eyes,
muscle aches, dizziness,
fatigue. |
| |
|
|
Distinctive bleeding into
the skin (petechae, purpura,
ecchymoses) due to damage to
the vascular endothelium
(lining cells of the blood
vessels). |
| |
|
|
Bleeding in internal organs,
or from the mouth, eyes, or
ears. |
| |
|
|
Delirium, seizures |
|
|
Airborne and Contact
precautions pending definite
identification. |
| |
|
|
Maximum containment measures
for all lab specimens! |
| |
|
|
Only Crimean-Congo VHF and
Lassa fever have effective
post exposure prophylaxis. |
|
|
Figure 13: (Bray, 2012). |
Diagnosis of any of the viral
hemorrhagic fevers relies primarily
on initial provider awareness of
observable symptoms, as well as
available history that can be
provided by patient or family. While
laboratory testing may be helpful to
spot leukopenia and
thrombocytopenia, along with protein
and blood in the urine, a definitive
laboratory diagnosis requires
specific virologic testing which is
generally available only through the
CDC or the US Army Medical Research
Institute of Infectious Disease
located in Frederick, Maryland. Even
ELISA testing is of limited aid.
While detection can be made of early
immunoglobulin antibody response
during the acute phase, test results
tend to take from 3 to 10 days
(Dire, 2011).
Ricin
Ricin is a plant toxin derived from
a protein found in the beans of the
castor plant. It has been one of the
most widely used biologic weapons of
the last several decades due in
great part to the combination of
high toxicity and relative ease of
production. Ricin is extremely toxic
to cells and acts by inhibiting
protein synthesis. The effects of
ricin exposure center on its method
of delivery. Inhalation exposure
causes primarily breathing and lung
problems. If ingested, ricin causes
symptoms in the GI tract. If
injected, cell death occurs at the
area of injection and the toxin
affects any tissues and organ
systems taking it up.
|
Bio Agent |
Signs & Symptoms |
Handling |
|
Ricin Inhalation
|
|
Sudden onset nasal & throat
congestion, nausea and
vomiting, itching of eyes,
tightness in the chest,
difficulty breathing
progressing to severe
respiratory distress and
possible death. |
|
|
Ricin is not contagious,
though standard precautions
should be maintained. |
| |
|
|
No post exposure prophylaxis
is available. |
|
|
Ricin Ingestion |
|
Nausea, vomiting, severe
cramping, bloody stools &/or
emesis, shortness of breath,
tachycardia, diaphoresis. |
|
|
Ricin Injection |
|
Flu like symptoms, body
aches, nausea, vomiting,
pain and swelling at the
injection site. Severe
exposure results in both
local and diffuse tissue
death and GI bleeding, as
well as widespread liver,
spleen, and kidney damage. |
|
|
Figure 14: (Dire, 2011). |
Diagnosis of ricin poisoning relies
on a combination of clinical and
epidemiologic factors. Ricin does
not occur naturally but must be
produced; therefore, exposure
history is essential to providing a
setting for contamination such as
may occur in a terror event where a
group of people are purposely
exposed to the toxin. Awareness of
numbers of clients being admitted
with similar symptoms should spark a
high level of suspicion in health
care facilities. Confirmation of
ricin poisoning can be made by
either ELISA analysis or by PCR
(Polymerase Chain Reaction) testing
which is able to detect the presence
of castor bean DNA.
Weapons of mass destruction that are
of biological origin possess a
uniquely mobile feature (human
carriers) that circumvents logical
prediction and response methods.
People do not stay put, especially
when they are fearful. As the vast
majority of biological weapons have
incubation periods, those initially
exposed may travel far from the
initial point of contact before
becoming aware there is a problem.
This results in secondary spread of
the warfare agent from the movement
of those initially exposed.
Identification of the disease that
is spreading is of utmost
importance, since the
transmissibility of infection must
be known in order to plan
appropriate containment for the
spread of the disease. Diseases that
are transmissible through casual
contact, by nonhuman vectors, or by
respiratory droplets carry high
rates of secondary infections,
whereas other diseases pose little
risk to those not initially
infected.
|
HIPAA Privacy Rules expressly
PERMIT personal health information
(PHI) sharing for public health
purposes without authorization. |
|
|
(Privacy Rights Clearinghouse, 2012)
|
The threat of nuclear and
radioactive weaponry is just as real
today as it was during the cold war
when "fallout drills" blared
throughout elementary schools across
the nation. Some terrorism experts
believe the risk for use of
radiological weapons of mass
destruction is actually higher now
than it has ever been before! The
very real possibility of such an
event within the United States makes
it vital that healthcare staff be on
the lookout for the signs and
symptoms of radioactive
contamination.
Nuclear and Radioactive agents are
categorized separately, nevertheless
are closely related. Nuclear weapons
are by definition instruments of
mass destruction that have a primary
focus related to explosive impact
and physical damage. Radioactive
dispersion weapons differ in that
they are all about radiation
fallout. With radioactive weapons,
the primary focus is to frighten and
sicken people while making buildings
or land unusable for extended
periods of time.
A nuclear explosion creates
destruction and demolition by means
of a huge concussion wave created by
the explosion. The heat and debris
spray of radioactive particles
(fallout) associated with a nuclear
explosion are secondary effects.
Survivors of a nuclear explosion
should be triaged and cared for like
the survivors of any large-scale
explosive disaster. Radiation
specific care should be added when,
and if it is needed.
Radiological dispersion devices (RDDs)
are used specifically for the spread
of radiation emitting material over
a wide area. An RDD might not
directly kill large numbers of
people, yet the degree of terror and
societal disruption caused by its
use would be almost indescribable.
An RDD is often referred to as a
"dirty bomb", and tends to consist
of conventional (e.g. non-nuclear)
explosives wrapped in some sort of
container containing low-grade
fissionable material or radioactive
waste. As a weapon, an RDD is simple
to produce and does not require
extensive technology to arm and
deploy. The effect of exploding this
type of device would be to spread
radioactive debris over a wide area,
creating an area of lingering
illness and suffering far beyond the
effect of conventional explosives.
|
Prevalence of Radiologic Materials |
Some experts believe that the
concern over being contaminated by
a radiation producing substance is
one of those things that would spark
fear far beyond the actual potential
for injury. A radiologic incident
would lead to a "rush" on local
hospitals and health facilities, as
well intentioned, yet fearful people
seek reassurance and assistance.
This would keep staff from those who
truly need their services.
Radioactive weapons of mass
destruction may not incorporate an
explosion at all. Radiation emitting
material can be distributed by means
of a passive dispersion device. The
can be as simple as hand sown
radioactive powders or waste
products used to contaminate a
neighborhood or product, such as a
playground or a batch of cosmetics.
Radiation emitting compounds could
slowly accumulate in an individuals
body without any easily recognizable
warning signs occurring. Paradigms
need to be changed, segregating the
horror of a nuclear explosion from
the insidious poisoning that might
be caused by the use of radiological
weaponry. Healthcare professionals
need to be aware of signs of
radioactive weapons.
Diagnosis
Medical effects from radiation fall
into two general categories, acute
and chronic. Effects depend on the
dose, duration of exposure, means of
exposure, and the type of radiation.
High yield energy exposure to
radiation can occur during the
detonation of a nuclear weapon or by
being in the presence of a nuclear
reaction without an explosion, such
as when high-grade nuclear material
is allowed to reach a critical mass
releasing large amounts of gamma and
neutron radiation. These high-energy
events often result in immediate
mortality from burns and tissue
destruction. For those who survive
the initial radiation release,
advanced medical treatments and
supportive care can be lifesaving.
Should exposure to radiation occur
over a prolonged period of time, at
lower levels, or without a single
catastrophic event to mark the
presence of radiation, it may well
be very difficult to identify.
Seeing large numbers of people with
vague nonspecific symptoms, skin
rashes, burns, or tender areas with
abnormal redness may indicate the
use of a radiological weapon.
Involved tissues begin to display
disruption in mitosis, motility,
cell growth, and permeability.
Actively dividing cells are the most
affected. The systems most
vulnerable include gastrointestinal
mucosal cells and hematopoetic
tissues (especially lymphocytes and
primitive stem cells).
Spermatogenesis and the granulosa
cells of the ovary are also very
sensitive. The result of radiation
exposure in the long term is often
manifested by sterility and general
syndromes related to the
physiological response to radiation
exposure (Dainiak, 2012).
Acute Radiation Syndrome (ARS) is
also referred to as radiation
toxicity or radiation sickness.
Cellular sensitivity is a key
component in acute symptoms of
radiation exposure, with the most
rapidly dividing cells demonstrating
a heightened effect to radiation.
ARS is an acute illness caused by
irradiation of a large portion of
the body by a high dose of
penetrating radiation in a very
short period of time, usually
exposure for a mere matter of
minutes. One of the lead factors in
this syndrome is depletion of
immature parenchymal stem cells in
tissues (Dainiak, 2012).
|
The Four Stages of Acute Radiation Syndrome |
Cutaneous Radiation Syndrome often
occurs in conjunction with ARS. Skin
damage from the radiation exposure
may develop early, within one to two
days, or it may take years to fully
manifest. Early damage may even
start to show within a few hours
after exposure and can include
swelling, itching, and redness of
the skin (like severe sunburn). The
area and body region showing damage
will be related to the localized
dose of the skin that comes in
contact with the radiation, and can
provide important early clues as to
the nature of the exposure, which
has occurred. The skin may heal for
a short time, followed by the return
of swelling, itching, and redness
days or weeks later. Complete
healing of the skin may take from
several weeks up to a few years
depending on the radiation dose the
persons skin received.
Neurovascular Radiation Syndrome,
sometimes called cerebrovascular
syndrome or CNS (Central Nervous
System) syndrome, results from the
damage caused by ionizing radiation
to cells in the central nervous
system. Typically, it is the result
of very high radiation doses.
Symptoms may begin after only a few
hours, or may not start for days. A
steady severe deterioration of
mental status is generally first
noticed, followed by coma and often
death.
|
Neurovascular Radiation Syndrome |
|
The early presence (within
minutes of exposure) of
fever, hypotension, and
major impairment of
cognitive function, along
with severe prodromal
symptoms (eg, anorexia,
nausea, vomiting) suggests
exposure to a supralethal
dose of radiation. |
| |
|
|
Lesser, but still fatal,
exposures to the central
nervous system present with
persistent and severe nausea
and vomiting, accompanied by
headache, neurologic
deficits, and abnormal
cognition. Signs and
symptoms include
disorientation, confusion,
loss of balance, and
seizures. Physical
examination may show
papilledema, ataxia and
reduced or absent deep
tendon and corneal reflexes.
A latent period of a few
hours of apparent
improvement is common, but
within five to to six hours
diarrhea, respiratory
distress, fever, and
cardiovascular collapse
ensue. The final picture may
mimic that of sepsis with
hypotension, cerebral edema,
increased intracranial
pressure, cerebral anoxia,
with death typically in
about two days time. |
|
|
Figure 17: (Dainiak, 2012). |
Gastrointestinal Radiation Syndrome
results from the ionizing effect of
radiation damaging the rapidly
dividing cells composing the
intestinal lining. Typically, it is
associated with a single exposure to
a radiation source. The onset of
symptoms is generally two to ten
days post exposure. Often there is
an abrupt onset of diarrhea when the
symptoms occur, and associated
severe fluid loss, frequently with
hemorrhage. Treatment focuses on
massive fluid and electrolyte
replacement and aggressive control
of opportunistic intestinal
bacterial infections. In most cases,
those suffering with
gastrointestinal syndrome will also
face hematopoetic syndrome. When
gastrointestinal symptoms are mild,
generally limited to one or two
episodes of diarrhea with associated
abdominal pain, prognosis for an
eventual recovery is very
encouraging.
Hematopoetic Radiation Syndrome,
sometimes referred to as Bone Marrow
syndrome, results from induced
apoptosis (metabolic cell death) of
delicate cells such as stem cells in
the bone marrow and lymphatic
organs. Symptoms include bleeding,
infection, and anemia. Significant
drops in blood cell counts may be
seen anywhere from an hour to two
days post exposure. The drop in cell
counts may last from weeks to
months. Supportive care allows time
for the diminished stem cells to be
replaced, and even in those
individuals who suffer from complete
stem cell die off; bone marrow and
stem cell transplants can aid the
slow process of recovery.
Treatment
Early management at the incident
scene or in an emergency department
should follow basic triage criteria.
It is important to assume that all
victims are either contaminated, by
physical radioactive material on
skin or absorbed by ingestion or
inhalation. Preliminary
decontamination such as removal of
clothing and washing of skin should
decrease external contamination by
90 to 95 percent. Persons at the
scene of a radiologic incident who
show no, or minor, injuries should
be relocated to a staging area
upwind of the site (but not at a
hospital, in order to decrease
congestion of emergency facilities).
Evaluation and decontamination can
then proceed at a more controlled
pace (Wingard & Dainiak, 2012).
Signs and symptoms of radiation
exposure can be initially quite
vague. Special attention should be
placed on history taking,
emphasizing location of person
related to the incident, duration of
possible exposure, and the exact
time that the exposure occurred.
Careful observation for the presence
of nausea, gastric symptoms (e.g.,
cramping, diarrhea), fatigue, fever,
or mental changes should be made
with exact times of occurrence and
duration of episodes noted. These
details will play an important role
when estimation of degree of
radiation exposure is made, around
which care planning will revolve.
Laboratory testing should be as
thorough and wide ranging as
permitted as comparisons of initial
results with those obtained over the
following days, weeks and months
have an important role to play in
care. Careful collection of bodily
excretions can be helpful, for
example, the collection of bilateral
nasal swabs within the first hour
post incident can provide a measure
by which the amount of radioactive
particles inhaled can be estimated.
Blood tests such as a CBC with white
blood cell differential and platelet
count is important, as are routine
chemistry profiles. Please note the
time of collection carefully because
of time sensitive changes that may
occur in the lymphocyte count.
When internal contamination is
suspected, action can be taken to
minimize damage by reducing the
absorption of radioactive material
and promoting rapid excretion from
the body using binding agents and
cathartics. Strategies to consider
include (Wingard & Dainiak, 2012):
|
Blocking organ uptake by use
of oral potassium iodide (KI)
if radioiodine is suspected
as a potential contaminant.
|
| |
|
|
Gastric washing to remove
radioactive material. This
tends to be most effective
within 1-2 hours of
ingestion of contaminated
material. |
| |
|
|
Antacids may be indicated to
reduce gastrointestinal
absorption. Aluminum
hydroxide is especially
effective if strontium has
been ingested. Magnesium
sulfate will bind radium.
|
| |
|
|
Cathartics like phospho-soda
or biscodyl will rapidly
increase intestinal transit
time. They may be taken
orally or as an enema.
|
| |
|
|
Pharmacologic doses of
sodium bicarbonate, orally
or intravenously, are useful
and safe counter measures
for uranium exposure; though
uranium is not a likely
component of an RDD. |
| |
|
|
Tritium is susceptible to
induced diuresis by forcing
fluids, and barium sulfate
or aluminum phosphate orally
and will reduce the effects
of ingested strontium.
|
| |
|
|
Studies for the oral use of
Prussian blue for cesium and
thallium contamination by
ingestion have led to its
approval for that use by the
FDA. |
If exposure levels hint that a
hematopoetic event is likely, any
open wound repairs, severe burn
debridement, or any other
anticipated surgical procedure must
be done on an emergency basis and
sutured completely closed within
forty-eight hours after radiation
exposure. This is due to the
anticipated blood cell count changes
that will drastically affect
granulation and healing once they
set in.
Explosives often fail to be listed
among Weapons of Mass Destruction
simply because we are used to them.
Concussive explosive devices are
readily available worldwide and
hardly a day goes by without a major
media story, either in the news or
entertainment media, talking about
them. Explosives are easy to
transport and operate without
special training. They tend to be
cheap, effective, and efficient.
They can also be produced in large
quantities using readily available
components, as we have seen
portrayed by the Oklahoma City
Bombing that left 168 people dead,
and many more injured. The fact that
they are readily available worldwide
brings a sort of casual regard to
weapons possessing the potential to
create multiple casualties at the
flick of a switch.
|
Remembering Explosive Weapons Attacks |
|
1995, April - Oklahoma City
Federal Building bombed with
home-made explosive device
168 killed. |
| |
|
|
2001, September 11 -
Concussive explosions from
the impact of hijacked
jetliners destroy the New
York World Trade Center
Towers. 3,350+ killed,
10,000+ injured. |
| |
|
|
2004, March - Madrid, Spain.
Bombs placed on 4 commuter
trains explode. 190 killed,
1,800+ injured. |
| |
|
|
And many, many other
incidents... |
|
|
Figure 18 |
An explosive is simply any material
that when induced into a chemical
reaction converts rapidly from a
solid (or a liquid) into an
expanding gas. The damage created by
explosives is mainly due to the
tremendous atmospheric pressure
increase they create, which is
forced outward from where the
original substance has expanded.
This brutal atmospheric expansion is
referred to as a positive pressure
wave, or blast wave, due to the
almost instantaneous pressure force
it holds. It is easy to forget that
following such a rapid, forceful
expansion a negative pressure zone
is created. This negative pressure
wave immediately follows the
expanding blast wave causing
displaced air in which myriads of
small fragments displaced by the
blast rush in to fill the void
created by the initial positive
pressure wave.
Few civilian medical personnel have
experience in handling the pattern
of damage caused by the use of a
large explosive device. The ability
to inflict mass casualties instantly
makes explosives a nightmare for
emergency services. Multiple levels
of trauma are generated within a few
seconds time and very few regions
are set up to do the intense level
of triage and transport necessary.
This tends to result in what some
refer to as "Triage Reversal" or
"Upside-Down" care.
Triage reversal occurs immediately
after any large explosive event.
This is where the less severely
wounded quickly find their way to
emergency rooms and other medical
facilities, clogging the care system
hopelessly. By the time more
severely wounded can be transported,
local healthcare systems already
waiver on the brink of collapse.
This is not a failure of emergency
management services (EMS) personnel.
The self-mobile, or walking wounded,
simply "go around" heavily burdened
first responders. They find their
own way to nearby hospitals and
facilities, and it requires a fluid,
well-rehearsed response by local
staff to coordinate the delivery of
care.
Explosive devises are often used as
dispersal mechanisms for other acts
or forms of weapons of mass
destruction. An explosive can
rupture chemical storage tanks,
fling chemicals, biological agents,
or radioactive materials into the
air and surrounding environment. Any
explosion must therefore be the
subject of scrutiny and treated as a
crime scene. As a matter of health,
let us take a closer look at
explosives as a weapon of mass
destruction and the impact on care
it delivers.
An explosion produces a unique
pattern of injury. The injuries
found after such events are the
result of the composition and amount
of the chemically active materials
involved, what was in the
surrounding environment, and the
delivery method of the explosive.
The delivery method may be the
product of unfortunate circumstances
like an electrical fire igniting
highly flammable materials or the
purposeful ignition of a bomb. Other
important factors are the distance
between each victim and the blast
source, any intervening protective
barriers or environmental hazards,
and secondary sources of injury such
as flung debris, resulting fires or
structural collapse. Because
large-scale explosions are
infrequent, blast-related injuries
present triage, diagnostic, and
management challenges to those
providing emergency care.
|
The HIGH's and LOW's of Explosives |
High order explosions have a unique
injury pattern as compared to low
order explosive blasts in that the
very force of the supersonic
pressure wave created can pick up
and slam people, cars, basically any
object, into stationary or fixed
materials. There is a dramatic
increase in projectile injuries with
HE explosions, as debris, both large
and small, becomes a forceful hail
of injury producing items. Beyond
the cascade of injury from debris,
projectiles are specific injury
patterns frequently seen in high
order explosive concussive events.
These injuries patterns are referred
to as traumatic, lung, ear, brain,
and delayed injuries.
Traumatic Blast Injuries
Penetrating and blunt trauma to body
surfaces is the most common injury
seen among blast survivors. Wounds
can be, and often are, grossly
contaminated. Immediate
concentration is on prevention of
blood loss followed by later
cleaning and debridement. Consider
the use of delayed primary closure
and assess tetanus status. Ensure
close follow-up of wounds for
infection. Air embolism following a
blast injury is common and can
present as stroke, myocardial
injury, acute abdomen, blindness,
deafness, spinal cord injury, or
claudication. Hyperbaric oxygen
therapy may be effective in some
cases of air embolism.
Lung Blast Injuries
"Blast lung" is a horrific direct
consequence of a high explosive
over-pressurization wave. It is the
most common fatal primary blast
injury among those who survive the
initial concussive explosion event.
Signs of blast lung are usually
present at the time of initial
evaluation, but have been reported
as late as 48 hours after the
explosion. Blast lung is
characterized by the clinical triad
of apnea, bradycardia, and
hypotension. Pulmonary injuries vary
from scattered petechiae to
confluent hemorrhages. Blast lung
should be suspected for anyone with
dyspnea, cough, hemoptysis, or chest
pain following an explosion. Blast
lung produces a characteristic
"butterfly" pattern on chest X-ray.
A chest X-ray is recommended for all
persons exposed to a blast and a
prophylactic chest tube (thoracotomy)
is recommended before general
anesthesia or air transport if blast
lung is suspected.
Ear Blast Injuries
Primary blast injuries of the
auditory system occur frequently yet
can be easily overlooked. The extent
of auditory injury tends to be
dependent on the orientation of the
ear to the blast pressure wave.
Tympanic membrane perforation or
rupture is the most common injury to
the middle ear. Signs of ear injury
are usually present at time of
initial evaluation and should be
suspected for anyone presenting with
hearing loss, tinnitus, otalgia
(e.g. pain in the ear), vertigo,
bleeding from the external canal,
tympanic membrane rupture, or
mucopurulent otorhea. All patients
exposed to a blast event should have
an otologic assessment and
audiometry as soon as can be
arranged.
Abdominal Blast Injuries
Gas-containing sections of the GI
tract are areas that are very
vulnerable to primary blast effect.
Damage frequently seen includes
immediate bowel perforation,
hemorrhage ranging from small
petechiae to large hematomas,
mesenteric shear injuries, solid
organ lacerations, and testicular
rupture. Blast abdominal injury
should be suspected in anyone
exposed to an explosion with
abdominal pain, nausea, vomiting,
hematemesis, rectal pain, tenesmus,
testicular pain, unexplained
hypovolemia, or findings suggestive
of an acute abdomen. Be aware that
clinical findings may be absent
until the onset of sepsis or other
complications.
Brain Blast Injuries
Primary blast waves can cause
concussions or traumatic brain
injury (TBI) even without a direct
blow to the head by a physical
object. Consider the proximity of
the victim to the blast particularly
when there are complaints of
headache, fatigue, poor
concentration, lethargy, depression,
anxiety, insomnia, or other
constitutional symptoms.
Delayed Blast Injuries
Compartment syndrome, rhabdomyolysis,
and acute renal failure are
associated with structural collapse,
prolonged extrication, severe burns,
and some poisonings. Consider the
possibility of exposure to inhaled
toxins and poisonings in both
industrial and criminal explosions.
Treatment
Timing related to explosive
incidents and local impact on
emergency treatment facilities is a
repeated frustration for medical
care systems. It is not uncommon for
the first trickle of "walking
wounded" to arrive at nearby medical
facilities in a matter of minutes
from the occurrence of a large
explosion, at times even before
official notification of an
explosive incident has been
received. Area emergency services
personnel must be able to
immediately implement local disaster
planning measures upon arrival of
the first responders to the scene.
Prompt notification of all area
healthcare facilities should create
a "ripple effect" as each facility
begins to put into place their own
prepared disaster plans. Be aware
that the size or nature of
particular events, especially those
related to a WMD, may trigger the
implementation of a regional
disaster plan.
|
As a Health Professional, Can YOU? |
Hard-earned experience has shown
that by the end of the first hour
following the use of an explosive
device as a weapon of mass
destruction approximately half of
the "first-wave" of casualties will
have already arrived at the nearest
medical facilities. These tend to be
the least injured survivors of the
event. It is important not to allow
medical services to become bogged
down when dealing with these
injuries. In many instances, the
more severely injured survivors of
an explosion will not even begin
arriving at the closest facilities
for 45 to 90 minutes after the blast
occurs. This gives hospitals a small
window of time in which to implement
their disaster response plan and
begin arrangements to bolster
staffing numbers. Use your first
hour wisely!
Be sure to employ this window of
time to obtain and record details
concerning the nature of the
explosion, any potential toxic
exposures, and initial casualty
estimates from police, fire, EMS,
ICS (incident command system), the
health department, or even reliable
news sources. Should the report of
structural collapse occur, be sure
to anticipate an increase in the
severity of injuries as well as
further time delays in the arrival
of severe casualties.
Good efficient triage is a both a
blessing and a burden. The absolute,
most critical thing that is needed
on the scene of any event of mass
destruction is a reliable, uniform
method for rapidly determining where
the resources that are immediately
available can best be applied.
|
Triage is a word of French origin that
emphasizes the context of sorting, or sifting.
The term is attributed to the battlefields of
France where the practice of triage became
formalized, with an effort to systematically
sort the wounded into those who could be saved
by medical interventions, and those who could
not. |
|
Figure 21 |
There is no uniform triage system in
the United States. One common triage
practice currently in use, according
to the American College of Emergency
Physicians, is a 1-2-3
classification assignment system
initiated at the time of patient
entry into a hospital emergency
department. Allocation decisions are
at that time made on an "as needed"
basis, often by an experienced
nurse, with the emphasis on ensuring
that unstable or potentially
unstable patients be seen rapidly
while those deemed "not likely to
deteriorate" wait for care. Ever
more rapid response by EMS to
disaster scenes has shown that
traditional triage systems have
little use outside of the emergency
room setting.
Establishment of more in-the-field
comprehensive systems has prompted
creation of several useful
methodologies over the past decades,
a good example of which is the
simple, effective triage assessment
system known as the S.T.A.R.T.
System.
START stands for Simple Triage and
Rapid Treatment and originated
during the 1980s in Newport Beach,
California by the cooperative
efforts of local fire department and
hospital personnel. The START system
emphasizes rapid classification of
injury victims by senior on-site
personnel using practiced rapid
assessments, typically under one
minute per victim. High visibility
color-coded priority tags are then
used to minimize confusion at the
scene.
|
Simple Triage and Rapid Treatment |
Regardless of the triage system
employed, all emergency service and
first response hospital staff must
be familiar with the system that is
in place locally and participate in
periodic drills in order to exercise
knowledge and skills.
Decontamination is the physical
process of removing the chemicals,
biological agents, or radioactive
materials from people, equipment,
and the environment. Residual
hazardous materials covering those
who have been exposed directly are
themselves a source of ongoing
exposure to others. These residuals
pose a risk of secondary exposure to
first responders and healthcare
personnel. Immediate decontamination
is a major treatment priority for
those with chemical weapon agent
exposure.
Initial decontamination involves
removing all contaminated clothes
and items from the affected person
and then washing the body thoroughly
with warm water and soap. Be aware
that hot water and vigorous
scrubbing may actually worsen the
effects by increasing chemical
absorption into the skin.
Vapor exposure alone may not require
decontamination. If it is not known
whether the exposure was to a vapor
or an aerosolized liquid,
decontaminate.
Make sure victims are able to
breathe, as respiratory effects are
common with the majority of chemical
warfare agents. Ideally,
decontamination will take place as
close as possible to the site of
exposure to minimize duration of
exposure and prevent further spread.
Hospitals receiving contaminated
people may establish an area outside
the Emergency Department in which to
perform initial decontamination.
Portable decontamination equipment
with showers and run-off water
collection systems are commercially
available. All hospitals should have
the capacity to safely decontaminate
at least one person at a time.
Immediate decontamination within 2
minutes of exposure is the most
important intervention for people
who have skin exposure to mustard
agents. Any effects on living tissue
caused by chemical mustard will
result in irreversible cell damage
to that tissue. If an exposure takes
place and a person shows no obvious
signs or symptoms, decontamination
is still urgent. If exposure is
suspected, immediately remove
clothing and wash the skin with soap
and water. Eye exposure requires
immediate irrigation with copious
amounts of saline or water. Even
delayed decontamination serves a
purpose as it prevents spread of the
chemical to other parts of the body
as well as protecting emergency care
personnel from further contact
exposure. Liquid blister agent
contamination poses a high risk for
emergency care personnel. The use of
PPE (personal protective equipment)
that is impervious to the highly
soluble agents is necessary.
The presence of radiological
contamination can be readily
confirmed by passing a radiation
detector (radiac dosimetry device or
Geiger counter) over a persons
body. The need for radiological
decontamination should not interfere
with emergent medical care. Unlike
chemical weapon agents, the presence
of radioactive particles will not
cause acute injury to caregivers.
Decontamination measures that are
sufficient to remove chemical agents
are more than sufficient to remove
superficial radiological
contamination (Wingard & Dainiak,
2012).
That said, please be aware that it
is important to initiate
decontamination of victims exposed
to a radiation weapon as soon as
possible, and usually this will be
done prior to arrival at a medical
facility. Decontamination of
multiple casualties resulting from a
radiological weapon is an enormous
task. Be aware that the process will
require a considerable amount of
time, therefore initial life
sustaining medical interventions
such as intubation for respiratory
distress, emergent control of
bleeding, or the initiation of
intravenous access should be done
prior to full decontamination
efforts.
Open wounds should be carefully
covered prior to decontamination, as
radioactive particles may move onto
the exposed tissue, especially when
there is blood or serous fluid to
adhere to. Contaminated clothing,
all jewelry and other items should
be carefully removed, placed in
sealed labeled plastic bags and
re-moved to a secure location
clearly marked as a contaminated
holding area. Bare skin and hair
should be thoroughly washed with
soap, and if at all possible, all of
the fluid and soilage from the
washing process should be gathered,
contained and labeled. It should
then be stored in an area clearly
marked as contaminated for latter
disposal in an appropriate manner.
Should the seriousness of injuries
mandate decontamination be delayed
the simple removal of outer clothing
and shoes along with a rapid washing
of exposed skin and hair will, in
most instances, effect a significant
reduction in the patients
contamination. Anti-contamination
protective clothing such as
coveralls should be worn by the
provider prior to the patient's
initial decontamination, but
standard universal precautions are
adequate for those treating limited
numbers of radiologically
contaminated patients. After
treating and decontaminating the
patient, providers themselves should
undergo decontamination.
Special care must be taken not to
irritate the skin. Experience with
victims of radiological
contamination has shown that should
the skin become erythematous, small
particles of radionuclides may be
absorbed directly through it.
Standard surgical irrigation
solutions should be used in liberal
amounts in all open wounds including
the abdomen and the chest as alpha
and beta-emitting particles left in
wounds will continue to cause
extensive local damage and may even
be absorbed into the systemic
circulation where they become
redistributed as internal
contaminants. If at all possible,
all irrigation solutions should be
removed by suction instead of
sponging and wiping, with the
contained solution being saved,
labeled and moved to an area clearly
marked as contaminated. Copious
amounts of water, normal saline, or
eye solutions are recommended for
suspected eye contamination.
Frequently a second, more deliberate
decontamination will be conducted on
arrival of victims to a medical care
facility. This is initiated to
prevent transfer of any residual
radiological particulate to areas of
the body previously uncontaminated,
as well as to limit possible
particulate contamination of
personnel. During this second, less
emergent decontamination, it is
common to obtain moist cotton swabs
of the nasal mucosa from both sides
of the nose. These should be
carefully labeled with an emphasis
on documentation of exact time the
sample was obtained, and sealed in
separate bags for later
determination of radioactive
particle inhalation.
Be aware that if decontamination
wash-water and soilage cannot be
contained and collected, local water
and sanitation authorities must be
notified so that appropriate action
can be taken.
All wound dressings, tourniquets,
and pressure pads initially applied
must be replaced with clean ones
after general decontamination is
complete. The original items were
placed prior to the body wash
process for protection of open
wounds, and must now be bagged,
labeled, and stored in an area
marked as contaminated.
|
Walking wounded are arriving at your facility
from the Conference Center explosion, having
made their way around street closures and points
set up for triage processing, decontamination,
and transport. Emergency Command has notified
all care centers of the risk that biologic
contaminants were released using the explosive
blast as a spread mechanism. Instructions are to
decontaminate all leaving the blast scene and
quarantine them pending further instructions.
No patients were supposed to arrive without
processing! Yet here they are, limping in,
holding makeshift dressings to lacerations and
injuries, covered with debris from the blast and
who knows what weaponized organism. Worse yet,
all mobile decontamination units have already
been rushed to the edge of the hot zone where
decontamination and triage was supposed to
occur. What to do?
Following written protocols, staff members
quickly establish a facility specific triage
area in a parking garage using plastic sheeting
retrieved from storage and water lines ran to
provide warm water for decontamination and
remove used water runoff into holding. Folding
privacy screens are set outside the quickly
established decontamination corridor and staff
in waterproof PPE and N-95 masks assist patients
to place all of their clothing and personnel
possessions into sealed clearly marked bags for
storage in a clearly marked area. Wounds are
covered, and soap with plentiful warm water used
to decontaminate skin and hair. Nasal swabs are
taken as a part of the process and carefully
conveyed to laboratory services. After drying
clean clothing are provided and processed
patients escorted to quarantine and further
treatment as warranted. |
After Action Notes:
|
Routine "pinch-nose"
surgical masks are designed
to be sneeze and droplet
guards, not infection
barriers. Use of N-95 face
contoured masks are designed
to filter out 95% of all
air-borne contaminants such
as smoke, dust, bacteria and
virus particles, they are
not oil resistant so use
around oily aerosols will
require another type of PPE.
|
| |
|
|
Experience working with
people in during disasters
has shown that alert
citizens always find ways
around help stations! Always
anticipate some "walking
wounded" to arrive from a
near disaster and have a
fallback plan for dealing
with the possible surge of
individuals arriving. |
| |
|
|
Past decontamination,
incident debriefings reveal
that a small number of
individuals unwilling to
part with sentimental
jewelry or completely
disrobe can create a full
stop to the time sensitive
process. Have a plan for
bringing time requiring
discussions out away from
the decontamination line.
Often "cant part with"
jewelry can be sealed into a
rip-proof plastic bag and
kept "in hand" during
decontamination, then opened
and cleaned under controlled
conditions later. Same sex
staff can accompany bashful
individuals, or reliable
family members can be
enlisted to assist. However
if personnel resources are
tight, defer dilemmas to the
last of the line so those
willing to be aided can
progress through without
delay. |
|
Routine hospital issue personal
protective equipment (PPE) will not
be adequate for most events
involving chemical weapon agents.
Surgical masks, for example, are
designed to protect the sterile
field of the patient from
contaminants generated by the
wearer, not protect the wearer.
While surgical masks are adequate to
catch most large-size particles in
the air, they offer no respiratory
protection against chemical vapors
and little against most biological
aerosols. Surgical or hospital issue
barrier gowns do not provide
adequate skin or mucous membrane
protection against warfare grade
chemicals. Latex gloves are also
inadequate against most weapon grade
chemicals. What is needed during the
receiving of chemical weapon victims
is clothing designed for the task.
The US Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA) has graded PPE into 4
levels based on the degree of
protection provided. Each level
consists of a combination of
respiratory equipment and clothing,
which protects against varying
degrees of inhalational, eye, or
skin exposure.
Level A protection consists of a
self-contained breathing apparatus
and a totally encapsulating
chemical-protective (TECP) suit.
Level A personal protective
equipment provides the highest level
of respiratory, eye, mucous
membrane, and skin protection.
Level B protection consists of a
positive-pressure respirator
(self-contained breathing apparatus
or supplied-air respirator) and
non-encapsulated chemical-resistant
garments, gloves, and boots. Tape
off all garment seams! Level B PPE
provides the highest level of
respiratory protection with a lower
level of skin protection.
Level C protection consists of an
air purifying respirator (APR) and
non-encapsulated chemical-resistant
clothing, gloves, and boots. Level C
personal protective equipment
provides the same level of skin
protection as level B, with a lower
level of respiratory protection.
Level D protection consists of
standard work clothes without a
respirator. In hospitals, level D
consists of surgical gown, mask, and
latex gloves. Be aware that level D
provides no true respiratory
protection and only minimal skin
protection.
Primary exposure to chemical warfare
agents occurs by inhaling chemical
gas or vapor as well as by direct
contact of the eyes or skin to
chemical vapor or liquid. Because
victims from the "hot zone" or area
where the weapon of mass destruction
was used may have had minimal or no
decontamination, healthcare staff
may be required to take extra
precautions to minimize the spread
of residual Chemical Weapons Agents
(CWAs) onto themselves, or others.
Chemical-protective clothing
consists of garments made from
varying layers of materials. Each
layer serves to protect against
different hazards. At the highest
protection level, aluminum-lined
vapor-impermeable garments are
available.
Incoming victims known to have been
exposed to a CWA vapor from a
volatile liquid (such as a nerve or
blistering agent), warrant a higher
level of protection for staff, as
low levels of chemical agents may
continue to be exhaled or exuded. In
most instances, a small number of
staff with level C PPE and
air-purifying respirators can assume
the task of conducting
decontamination. Once
decontamination is complete and the
threat level assessed, standard
level D precautions (universal
precautions) may be adequate.
Health Alert Network
In response to the threats of
biological and chemical terrorism,
the Center for Disease control has
implemented an internet Health Alert
Network (HAN). The online address of
HAN is http://www2a.cdc.gov/han/Index.asp.
The objectives of HAN are (CDC,
2013):
|
Ensure that each community
has rapid and timely access
to emergent health
information; a cadre of
highly trained professional
personnel; and
evidence-based practices and
procedures for effective
public health preparedness,
response, and service on a
24/7 basis. |
| |
|
|
Function as the Public
Health Information Networks
(aka PHINs) Health Alert
component. This includes
collaborating with federal,
state, and city/county
partners to develop
protocols and relationships
that will ensure a robust
interoperable platform for
the rapid exchange of public
health information. |
The HAN website notes the current
status in relative to risk of a
bioterrorism event, and has a direct
link to procedures for interim
recommended notification for local
and state public health department
leaders in the event of a
bioterrorist incident.
National Disaster Medical System
The National Disaster Medical System
(NDMS) has been established in order
to provide medical care and
transportation for disaster victims.
Any state can enlist the services of
the NDMS, which is able to assist
with care at the event site, can
evacuate individuals affected, and
is able to find beds for those
evacuated. A quick deployment design
of response teams allow them to go
anywhere in the country within hours
following an event of mass
destruction.
National Pharmaceutical Stockpile
The National Pharmaceutical
Stockpile (NPS) program advocated by
the Center for Disease Control (CDC)
is now in place. The NPS is a
standing emergency reserve of
supplies for use in times of
emergency. It is structured to be
able to provide both an immediate
response at any moment of need, and
a delayed response more targeted
toward specific task needs. The
initial response consists of ready
for delivery pharmaceuticals and
supplies able to arrive at the scene
of an emergency within 12 hours of a
Federal decision to provide
assistance. These packages allow for
both treatment and prophylaxis of
most man-made diseases and are
constantly being updated.
A second phase of the NPS program is
known as the 'Vendor-Managed
Inventory'. This consists of
providing additional pharmaceuticals
and supplies specifically targeted
toward the needs of local healthcare
workers, so that they can better
serve their patients during the
emergency. The Vendor-Managed
Inventory is capable of arriving at
the incident scene from 24-36 hours
after notification of a biological
attack.
After traumatic events, it is normal
to experience acute symptoms of
anxiety that dissipate over time.
However, some may go on to develop
psychiatric disorders, most commonly
post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
The cardinal features of PTSD
include:
|
Intrusive re-experiencing of
the trauma in the form of
nightmares or flashbacks |
|
|
|
|
Avoidance of reminders of
the trauma along with
emotional numbing |
|
|
|
|
Persistent symptoms of
autonomic hyperarousal
|
The best predictor of PTSD risk is
the degree of exposure to the
traumatic event. Those whose lives
are directly threatened, who are
physically injured, or who are
exposed to extremely horrifying or
grotesque events are at greatest
peril. However, all who have
exposure to the event are at
potential jeopardy, including family
members and friends, rescue workers,
healthcare providers, as well as
others in the local community.
As a healthcare worker, you, just
like those survivors you care for,
are at risk of experiencing what
psychologists refer to as a
traumatic incident, that is, an
incident that may involve exposure
to catastrophic events, severely
injured children or adults, dead
bodies or body parts, or even the
loss of someone you know or work
with. Often first responders and
initial care staff fail to
acknowledge the need to take care of
themselves, and ignore the need to
monitor their own emotional and
physical health. This is especially
true when recovery efforts stretch
into days or weeks.
|
Symptoms of Traumatic Incident Stress |
There are ways to ease the strain.
Seek professional help as soon as
possible, you are not alone! There
are also simple, effective methods
for helping yourself. Ways to begin
to ease the stress, to start to
heal.
 |
Pace yourself. The injured
will continue to trickle in
for a considerable time
after a WMD incident. Be
aware that rescue and
recovery efforts may
continue for days or even
weeks. |
|
|
|
 |
Take frequent rest breaks.
As little as two minutes of
down time can greatly help.
Mental fatigue over long
shifts can place staff at
greatly increased risk for
errors or injury. |
|
|
|
 |
Watch out for each other.
Co-workers may be intently
focused on a particular task
and may not see what you
can. |
|
|
|
 |
Be conscious of those around
you. Personnel who are
exhausted, feeling stressed
or even temporarily
distracted may place
themselves and others at
risk. |
|
|
|
 |
Maintain as normal a
schedule as possible -
regular eating and sleeping
are crucial! Make sure that
you drink plenty of fluids
such as water and juices.
|
|
|
|
 |
Whenever possible, take
breaks away from the work
area. Eat and drink in the
cleanest area available.
|
|
|
|
 |
Recognize and accept what
you cannot change - the
chain of command,
organizational structure,
waiting, equipment failures,
etc. |
|
|
|
 |
Talk to people when YOU feel
like it. You decide when you
want to discuss your
experience. Talking about an
event may be reliving it.
Choose your own comfort
level. |
|
|
|
 |
If your employer provides
you with formal mental
health support, use it! |
|
|
|
 |
Give yourself permission to
feel rotten: You are in a
difficult situation. |
|
|
|
 |
Recurring thoughts, dreams,
or flashbacks are normal -
do not try to fight them.
They will decrease over
time. |
|
|
|
 |
Communicate with your loved
ones at home as frequently
as possible |
Weapons of mass destruction come in
many forms. The damage they inflict
may occur at any time, in any place.
What is shared by these devastating
weapons is that they cause damage,
injury, and death to many, all
stemming from one incident, one
source. In recent years, health
services have had to deal with
several instances of mass
casualties. We have learned how
little it takes for local resources
to be stressed in their abilities to
cope. The possibility that such
agents of destruction might be used
in any of our neighborhoods mandates
a heightened level of preparation
and vigilance on the part of all
healthcare providers.
We know that the quick
implementation of a prepared,
practiced response plan can save
many lives. An awareness of what
injuries might result from each of
the various types of destructive
agents, or CBRNE of mass destruction
- Chemical, Biological, Radioactive,
Nuclear, Explosive - allows
healthcare and rescue personnel to
tackle the task of dealing with the
emergency in the most efficient
manner possible. Early triage of
survivors will make a huge impact on
the success of overall care efforts,
and all personnel who have any
dealings with a large scale
emergency must be aware of what
triage means and how to best aid in
timely, effective care for both
their patients and themselves.
Agency for Toxic Substances and
Disease Registry, (2011). Medical
Management Guidelines for Nerve
Agents. Department of Health and
Human Services. Retrieved from:
http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/mmg/mmg.asp?id=523&tid=93
on February 4, 2013.
Arnold, AL. (2009). Chemical
Warfare. eMedicine Health. Retrieved
from:
http://www.emedicinehealth.com/chemical_warfare/article_em.htm,
February 4, 2013
Beary, JF., et al. (2012). Chemical
Terrorism Diagnosis and Treatment of
Exposure to Chemical Weapons. In:
Hirsch MS (Ed.) UpToDate 21.1.
Waltham, MA.
Bray, M. (2012). Diagnosis and
Treatment of Ebola and Marburg
Hemorrhagic Fever. In: Hirsch MS
(Ed.) UpToDate 21.1. Waltham, MA.
Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention. (2005).Tularemia.
Retrieved from:
http://phil.cdc.gov/phil/galleries.asp?keyword=tularemia,
January 21, 2013.
Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention. (2006). Smallpox Lesions
on Skin of Trunk. Retrieved from:
http://www.bt.cdc.gov/agent/smallpox/smallpox-/courses/images/smallpox2.htm,
January 21, 2013.
Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention. (2012). Bioterrorism
Agents by Category. Retrieved from:
http://www.bt.cdc.gov/agent/agentlist-category.asp#catdef,
February 4, 2013.
Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention. (2012). Blast and Bomb
Injuries. Retrieved from:
http://emergency.cdc.gov/masscasualties/blastinjuryfacts.asp,
February 4, 2013.
Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention. (2013). Health Alert
Network. Retrieved from:
http://www2a.cdc.gov/han/Index.asp,
February 1, 2013.
Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention. (2012). Chemical Agents
by Category. Retrieved from:
http://www.bt.cdc.gov/agent/agentlistchem-category.asp,
February 3, 2013.
CHEMM. (2011). START Adult Triage
Algorithm. CHEMM Chemical Hazards
Emergency Management. U.S.
Department of Health and Human
Services. Retrieved from:
http://chemm.nlm.nih.gov/startadult.htm,
February 7, 2013.
Cox, RD. (2011). Hazmat. Medscape
eMedicine. Retrieved from:
http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/831240-overview,
February 7, 2013.
Crandall, JC. (2012). Phosgene
Exposure. Medscape eMedicine.
Retrieved from:
http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/832454-overview,
February 7, 2013.
Dainiak, N. (2012). Biology and
Clinical Features of Radiation
Injury in Adults. In: Hirsch MS
(Ed.) UpToDate 21.1. Waltham, MA.
Dire, DJ. (2011). CBRNE Biological
Warfare Agents. Medscape eMedicine.
Retrieved from:
http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/829613-overview.
February 7, 2013.
Eitzen, EM., & Takafuji, ET. (1997).
"Historical Overview of Biological
Warfare." In: Textbook of Military
Medicine, Medical Aspects of
Chemical and Biological Warfare,
1997. Published by the Office of The
Surgeon General, Pages 415-424.
Department of the Army, USA.
Holstege, CP. (2012).
3-Quinuclidinyl Benzilate Poisoning.
Medscape eMedicine. Retrieved from:
http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/833155-overview,
February 7, 2013.
Jagminas, L. (2011). CBRNE
Biological Warfare Mass Casualty
Management. Medscape eMedicine.
Retrieved from:
http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/831529-overview,
February 6, 2013.
Miller, J., & Broad, W. (2012).
"Fentanyl: Toxic Gas Turned Deadly".
Real Clear History. Retrieved from:
http://www.realclearhistory.com/2012/10/26/fentanyl_toxic_gas_turned_deadly_565.html,
February 7, 2013.
National Institute for Occupational
Safety and Health. (2010). Traumatic
Incident Stress. Retrieved from:
http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/traumaticincident,
February 6, 2013.
Nelson, LS. (2011). Hydrogen Cyanide
Poisoning. Medscape eMedicine.
Retrieved from:
http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/832840-overview,
February 7, 2013.
Privacy Rights Clearinghouse.
(2012). How Your Medical Information
Used and Disclosed - With and
Without Your Consent. Retrieved
from:
https://www.privacyrights.org/fs/fsC2/CA-medical-uses-disclosures,
February 16, 2013.
Public Health Emergency. (2005).
"Terrorism and Other Public Health
Emergencies: A Reference Guide for
Media". Office of the Assistant
Secretary for Preparedness and
Response. U.S. Department of Health
and Human Services. Retrieved from:
http://www.phe.gov/emergency/communication/guides/media/Documents/Forms/AllItems.aspx,
February 15, 2013.
Velez-Daubon, LI. (2012). CBRNE
Nerve Agents, Binary - GB2, VX2.
Medscape eMedicine. Retrieved from:
http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/831901-overview.
February 11, 2013
Wingard, JR. & Dainiak, N.
(2012).Treatment of Radiation Injury
in the Adult. In: Hirsch MS (Ed.)
UpToDate 21.1. Waltham, MA.
Woods, CW. (2012). Identifying and
Managing Casualties of Biological
Terrorism. In: Hirsch MS (Ed.)
UpToDate 17.2. Waltham, MA. |